Israel’s occupation: Who is most “Out of touch with reality”?
Posted on 27. Mar, 2012 by Alan Hart in Israel
Human Rights Council Meeting
By Alan Hart
If more proof was needed (some of us think it isn’t) that Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu lives in a fantasy world that exists only in his own deluded mind, his latest verbal assault on the UN Human Rights Council for its decision to appoint and despatch an independent international fact-finding mission “to investigate the implications of the (illegal) Israeli settlements on the civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights of the Palestinian people throughout the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem” is it.
The Council, Netanyahu said in his fury, has “an automatic majority against Israel”, is “hypocritical” and “out of touch with reality”. He added that “It should be ashamed of itself.”
There is, in fact, some substance to the charge that the UN Human Rights Council is hypocritical. There are many abuses of human rights in many countries which it does not investigate because the African, Asian and Latin American majority on the 47-member Council say “No”. So there is most certainly a case for saying that this particular UN body is hypocritical, even out of touch with some realities and, in that context, appears to be obsessed with Israel-Palestine.
But does that mean the decision of the UN Human Rights Council to set up an independent investigation of the implications of Israel’s on-going colonization of the West Bank including East Jerusalem should be treated with contempt and not taken seriously?
Netanyahu claims that it does.
In my opinion that Netanyahu claim deserves the judgement delivered about a different matter in a recent article by economist Paul Krugman for the New York Times. He was commenting on the claim by the Republican leadership in general and frontrunner Mitt Romney in particular that the high and rising price of gasoline in America is “thanks to an Obama administration plot.” Krugman wrote:
“This claim isn’t just nuts; it’s a sort of craziness triple play – a lie wrapped in an absurdity swaddled in paranoia.”
Netanyahu’s purpose was, of course, to encourage other powers led by America to use their influence to kill the UN Human Rights Council’s initiative before it takes on real life. And the early signs are in his favour. The U.S. ambassador to the UN in Geneva, Betty King, said the Council’s decision “harmed efforts to restart negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians.”
That has to be a joke given that there is no prospect of re-starting real and serious negotiations as long as Israel continues to consolidate its occupation of the West Bank, and as long as Netanyahu’s position is, in effect, that negotiations must end with the Palestinians surrendering on Israel’s terms.
I think it’s reasonable to imagine that when Ambassador King made her statement, she was aware that the Obama administration would be required by the Zionist lobby and its stooges in Congress to bully and intimidate the Human Rights Council into aborting its investigation.
While Netanyahu waits to see if the Obama administration will do his dirty work on this occasion, his government has cut all contact with the UN Human Rights Council and announced that it will prevent the Council’s team of independent investigators entering Israel or the occupied West Bank from Jordan.
Whichever way you look at it, the signs are that this particular mission of the UN Human Rights Council will be more than D.O.A. (Dead On Arrival). It will most likely be D.B.A (Dead Before Arrival)
In that event one of the questions in my mind will be this.
Will any mainstream Western media institution have the balls to offend Zionism by giving space or airtime to voices expressing outrage at Israel’s continuing immunity from what honest investigation would describe as crimes against humanity?
Contrary to what Netanyahu seems to think, the Palestinians are human and do have rights. And they, not Jews, are the victims in the true story of the making and sustaining of the conflict in and over Palestine that became Israel. (As I have written previously, Israeli and many other Jews need to feel they are the victims because victimhood is, it seems, what gives them meaning).
As for the answer to my headline question… Nobody is more out of touch with reality on the ground in the occupied West Bank than Netanyahu.
Footnote:
Of the 47 rotating member states of the UN Human Rights Commission, 36 voted in favour of the decision to investigate Israel’s illegal settlement activities, and 10 including the Czech Republic Romania, Hungary, Poland, Costa Rica, Italy and Spain abstained. The United States was the only country to vote against it.
Thirty-six states voted in favor of the decision, while ten states abstained, including the Czech Republic, Romania, Hungary, Poland, Costa Rica, Italy and Spain. The United States was the only country to vote against it.
member states of the UN Human Rights Council, 36 voted in favour of the decision to investigate the implications for the Palestinians of Israel’s illegal settlement activity on occupied West Bank, and 10 (including the Czech Republic, Romania, Hungary, Poland, Costa Rica, Italy and Spain) abstained. Only the U.S. voted against it.
loading...
Israel’s occupation: Who is most “Out of touch with reality”? | Opinion Maker | My Marketing File
27. Mar, 2012
[...] Israel’s occupation: Who is most “Out of touch with reality”? | Opinion Maker. News: Why should America burn? | Opinion Maker A question that every American must ask that why America should burn for israel. via Why should America burn? | Opinion Maker. RAW in Secret War Against Pakistan | Opinion Maker RAW in Secret War Against Pakistan | Opinion Maker. Obama In The Mirror | Opinion Maker Obama In The Mirror | Opinion Maker. How Greece Could Take Down Wall Street | Opinion Maker How Greece Could Take Down Wall Street | Opinion Maker. US Nuclear Weapons Unaccountable | Opinion Maker US Nuclear Weapons Unaccountable | Opinion Maker. Global Peace and Conflict Management | Opinion Maker Global Peace and Conflict Management | Opinion Maker. A 75th Anniversary for the American Dream | Opinion Maker A 75th Anniversary for the American Dream | Opinion Maker. Pakistan: Flogging a dead horse | Opinion Maker Pakistan: Flogging a dead horse | Opinion Maker. The Plot to Destroy the United States | Opinion Maker The Plot to Destroy the United States | Opinion Maker. Pakistan: Changing horses midstream | Opinion Maker Pakistan: Changing horses midstream | Opinion Maker. Pakistan: Post mortem of grievances of Balochistan | Opinion Maker Pakistan: Post mortem of grievances of Balochistan | Opinion Maker. Turkey: From Sick Economy to Vibrant Economic Workhorse | Opinion Maker Turkey: From Sick Economy to Vibrant Economic Workhorse | Opinion Maker. It’s the Right Moment for Churches to Pay Attention to Israel’s Occupation | My Catbird Seat It’s the Right Moment for Churches to Pay Attention to Israel’s Occupation | My Catbird Seat. #Romney: Out of Touch with Mainstream America | AFL-CIO NOW BLOG Romney: Out of Touch with Mainstream America | AFL-CIO NOW BLOG. Israel’s Last Chance to Strike Iran – NYTimes.com Israel’s Last Chance to Strike Iran – NYTimes.com. The Kindle Touch: Will It Burn Apple or Google? – Yahoo! Finance The Kindle Touch: Will It Burn Apple or Google? – Yahoo! Finance. #Nintendo: #WiiU will launch in time for 2012 holiday season, use touch-card tech – Tehran Times Nintendo: Wii U will launch in time for 2012 holiday season, use touch-card tech – Tehran Times. Handwriting recognition comes to Kindle Touch, thanks to Puzzazz | The Digital Home – CNET News Handwriting recognition comes to Kindle Touch, thanks to Puzzazz | The Digital Home – CNET News. Gauging Arab public opinion – Opinion – Al Jazeera English Gauging Arab public opinion – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. LET’S NOT FORGET THE OTHER OCCUPATION « Desertpeace LET’S NOT FORGET THE OTHER OCCUPATION « Desertpeace. Declaration of the Occupation of New York City | NYC General Assembly Declaration of the Occupation of New York City | NYC General Assembly. Occupy Trenton To Hold Seminar On How To Set Up An Occupation And Protest Occupy Trenton To Hold Seminar On How To Set Up An Occupation And Protest. Obama and the Nobel Peace Prize: Occupation Now! | End the Lie – Independent News Obama and the Nobel Peace Prize: Occupation Now! | End the Lie – Independent News. Massacres are the inevitable result of foreign occupation | Seumas Milne | Comment is free | The Guardian Massacres are the inevitable result of foreign occupation | Seumas Milne | Comment is free | The Guardian. US public radio journalist fired after calling Israeli occupation ‘brutal’ « Aletho News US public radio journalist fired after calling Israeli occupation ‘brutal’ « Aletho News. Univision goes neoconservative – Opinion – Al Jazeera English Univision goes neoconservative – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. #Romney takes us to infinity and beyond – Opinion – Al Jazeera English Romney takes us to infinity and beyond – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. UN chief urges end to Israeli occupation – Yahoo! News UN chief urges end to Israeli occupation – Yahoo! News. Canadian version of Wall Street occupation planned – Occupy America Social Network Canadian version of Wall Street occupation planned – Occupy America Social Network. College a series of scams and a debt maker – YouTube College a series of scams and a debt maker – YouTube. PressTV – ‘Palestine occupation equals apartheid’ PressTV – 'Palestine occupation equals apartheid'. Pushing Iran towards a nuclear bomb – Opinion – Al Jazeera English Pushing Iran towards a nuclear bomb – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. No Right To Protest In America: Occupation Of Wall Street Thwarted Thanks To Ignorant Police : No Right To Protest In America: Occupation Of Wall Street Thwarted Thanks To Ignorant Police :. The real ‘invented’ people – Opinion – Al Jazeera English The real 'invented' people – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. Mitchell and Cillizza Fawn All Over Herman Cain’s Pizza Song – Claim it Means He’s in Touch With Everyday Americans | Video Cafe Mitchell and Cillizza Fawn All Over Herman Cain's Pizza Song – Claim it Means He's in Touch With Everyday Americans | Video Cafe. Public opinion surprises – Glenn Greenwald – Salon.com Public opinion surprises – Glenn Greenwald – Salon.com. Mobile ‘Rootkit’ Maker Tries to Silence Critical Android Dev | Threat Level | Wired.com Mobile ‘Rootkit’ Maker Tries to Silence Critical Android Dev | Threat Level | Wired.com. OPINION: Drones Come to the US – Geopolitical Monitor OPINION: Drones Come to the US – Geopolitical Monitor. Israel’s Tragedy of ‘Victories’ | Consortiumnews Israel’s Tragedy of ‘Victories’ | Consortiumnews. The winners and losers of US policy on Iran – Opinion – Al Jazeera English The winners and losers of US policy on Iran – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. It’s All Here: TCHB! Coverage of the First Two Weeks of the Occupation Movement Sweeping the Nation | This Can’t Be Happening It's All Here: TCHB! Coverage of the First Two Weeks of the Occupation Movement Sweeping the Nation | This Can't Be Happening. Analysis: N.Korea’s missile-maker seen in key role in new regime – Yahoo! News Analysis: N.Korea's missile-maker seen in key role in new regime – Yahoo! News. Untangling the Web: Sensationalis… JPost – Opinion – Columnists Untangling the Web: Sensationalis… JPost – Opinion – Columnists. Untangling the Web: Newsaholics a… JPost – Opinion – Columnists Untangling the Web: Newsaholics a… JPost – Opinion – Columnists. Left Behind: Iraqis Who Helped US Occupation Forces Fear Revenge Attacks — News from Antiwar.com Left Behind: Iraqis Who Helped US Occupation Forces Fear Revenge Attacks — News from Antiwar.com. ‘Attack Iran’ and AIPAC’s infamous chutzpah – Opinion – Al Jazeera English 'Attack Iran' and AIPAC's infamous chutzpah – Opinion – Al Jazeera English. Labor Movement Rolls Into Wall Street Occupation | Economy | AlterNet Labor Movement Rolls Into Wall Street Occupation | Economy | AlterNet. Opinion | #Political #posturing and Iran: What does it have to do with us? | Seattle Times Newspaper Opinion | Political posturing and Iran: What does it have to do with us? | Seattle Times Newspaper. Activist Post: No right to protest in America: Occupation of Wall Street thwarted thanks to ignorant police Activist Post: No right to protest in America: Occupation of Wall Street thwarted thanks to ignorant police. Wall Street’s Second Occupation: The Rise of the NYPD’s Homeland Security State | Occupy Wall Street | AlterNet Wall Street’s Second Occupation: The Rise of the NYPD's Homeland Security State | Occupy Wall Street | AlterNet. Share this:ShareGoogle BuzzPrintDiggRedditStumbleUpon Tags: Israel 0 Comments – Leave a comment! « Previous Post [...]
Foo
28. Mar, 2012
I look at this as a good thing. The further Israel pushes itself away the from the international community the harder it gets for them to present lies that are automatically accept as "truth"
The Ineligible Candidate « Keys To Liberty
28. Mar, 2012
[...] COMMENTARY Israel’s occupation: Who is most “Out of touch with reality”? If more proof was needed (some of us think it isn’t) that Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu [...]
DDearborn
28. Mar, 2012
Hmmm
The thing that scares Israel and zionists in general more than anything else is the truth. That is why zionists around the world are passing laws to outlaw free speech, to outlaw legitimate historical investigation and research and has complete control of the international media. To Israel the truth is far more dangerous than a nuclear Iran.
Rehmat
28. Mar, 2012
Historically, the entire British mandated Palestine is occupied by Western Jews on behalf of the former and the new western colonial powers. The mainstream media will never allow criticism of Jewish Zionazi policies because 96% of it's owned by six Zionist families.
Being a West-supported imperial entity, Israel is genuinely affraid of free press and the international forums which condemn its policies once a while – the UN, Amnesty International, UNHRC, etc.
The Zionist regime is not ashamed of the fact that the UNHRC has passed 39 resolutions out of organization’s total 91 – demanding the Zionist entity to behave as a normal and civilized nation…..
http://rehmat1.wordpress.com/2012/03/27/lobby-israel-quits-unhrc-us-should-too/